How do I get my son back to throwing after arm pain?

Returning to throwing after arm pain requires four things in order: medical clearance for anything requiring it, identification of the contributors that caused the pain, a structured progressive reintroduction of throwing stress, and criteria for advancing that are based on response rather than on the calendar. Absence of pain at rest is not readiness.

Why resting and then throwing usually fails

The usual sequence looks reasonable. His arm hurt, he rested three or four weeks, the pain went away, so he went back out and threw.

Rest makes pain go away because rest removes the load. It changes nothing about why that load was a problem. When he picks the ball back up, every contributor is still in place, he is now deconditioned, and the tissue healed without stress on it. That combination is not a fresh start. It is a worse starting point than the one he was injured from.

The four steps, in order

One. Rule out what needs ruling out. If there was a pop, numbness or tingling, swelling, loss of motion, or pain that outlasted several days of rest, or if he is still growing, he needs a physician and likely imaging before anything else on this list. Nothing on this page substitutes for that.

Two. Find out why it happened. This is the step that gets skipped. Something put that much stress on that structure: a physical restriction, a movement pattern, how he prepares and recovers, how he trains, his workload across teams, his sleep. Usually several of those stacked together. Returning to throwing without addressing any of them rebuilds the same problem.

Three. Reintroduce throwing deliberately. Not throw a little and see how it feels. A structured progression that begins well below what he can tolerate and adds stress in controlled steps.

Four. Advance on response, not on dates. He moves to the next stage when his arm indicates he is ready, not when a particular Tuesday arrives.

What a structured return actually looks like

Our return protocols use a substitution approach. The athlete performs the same drills each day, but most repetitions begin with a low-stress implement and only a few are thrown with a baseball.

Over several weeks that ratio shifts. The low-stress repetitions come down, the baseball repetitions go up, until he is throwing the baseball for all of them. Because these athletes are returning from pain, we build in rest days during the first two weeks that a normal progression would not include.

The implement is not the point. The point is that he performs the movement throughout, while the stress climbs slowly enough to stay ahead of him.

Alongside that progression we work deceleration, connection, and the lower half, because rebuilding the throw without addressing what was overloading the arm produces a return visit a few months later.

Rules during the return

  • Any pain during a session ends that session. Not push through, not finish the set.
  • Ask the three questions every time: where is it, when does it happen, how long does it last.
  • Record a zero to ten rating after each session so you have a trend rather than a memory.
  • Apply the ramp rule. Every week completely off needs roughly two weeks of coming back.
  • Build the calendar backward from his arm, not forward from the next tournament.

When this doesn't apply

This page describes returning from arm pain that a movement and training approach can address. It is not post-surgical rehabilitation, and it is not a substitute for medical care. If a physician has placed your son on a specific protocol, that protocol governs. What we do begins after a physician has ruled out what needs ruling out.

Related questions

Video Transcript: How Do I Get My Son Back to Throwing After Arm Pain or an Arm Injury?

The Flaw of a Calendar-Based Return to Throwing

00:00

How do I get my son back to throwing after arm pain or an arm injury? Here's how this usually goes: a pitcher gets hurt and we rest him for 3 weeks, and then we go right back out there and start throwing the exact same way we were throwing before we got hurt.

00:09

Then the cycle continues and we're back to being hurt again. Feeling better and being ready are two completely different things. One of them depends on the athlete; the other one depends on the calendar, and the calendar is not the thing we should be going by.

00:20

Rest makes the pain go away, but it doesn't change any of the contributors that caused the injury to begin with. And so, we can't just rest and expect that we're going to have a different result.

00:28

We have to take some time, of course, to get things settled down, but then we have to begin to analyze what are the contributing factors that led to this injury, and how can we mitigate those as we ramp back up.

00:39

If all we do is rest, everything heals sort of in a chaotic manner. We removed the stress and the load that was creating the problem, but we didn't change anything that led to it. When we go right back, we're right back in the same boat again. Nothing has really changed significantly.

The Four Crucial Rules of Injury Onramping

00:51

So when we're ramping back up post-injury, we need to follow four rules in this exact order:

00:55

Rule number one: Rule out what needs to be ruled out. Was there a pop? Is there tingling? Is there numbness? Is it red hot, swollen, and tender? Is there a significant structural injury that we need to examine?

01:03

If you're a young guy with a suspected growth plate injury, we're going to need to get medical imaging for that. There's no substitute for that. You can't come to a pitching coach or a physical therapist as a substitute for an X-ray; you have to get medical intervention to get medical clearance first.

01:15

Rule number two: Find out why the injury happened. Now, that's the part everybody skips because it's really complex. It's never one thing—it's always a combination of variables that led to the perfect storm that created an environment where an injury could happen.

01:28

Sometimes it's their physical constraints, their movement patterns, their training history, or their workload. There are all kinds of contributors. We need to analyze those systematically and then begin to eliminate them so that we don't have a recurrence of the injury.

Reintroducing Throwing with Purposed Constraints

01:40

Rule number three: Reintroduce throwing, but with a purpose. Don't just start randomly throwing the exact same way you threw before you got hurt. Let's figure out what kind of constraint-led drills we can do to change the movement pattern.

01:50

We want to change the movement pattern implicitly, suddenly, and subconsciously so that the body begins to protect itself better and we don't end up with the exact same stresses that caused the injury in the first place.

Basing Progression on Physical Feedback, Not Dates

02:00

Rule number four: We have to advance with a plan and with a purpose, but one that's not based on the calendar or specific dates. The biggest enemy of an injured player is the calendar. We set these arbitrary limits and say you have to be ready within 6 weeks. Well, the body doesn't know the calendar; it will be ready when it's ready.

02:14

So, we have to base our progression on the information we get from the data that we collect and also from the physical feedback we get from the player. How does the arm feel? Use whatever metrics we can use to quantify that to objectively measure movement principles.

02:24

But also, does the arm feel okay? If it does, allow the freedom to extend and to advance. But if it doesn't, we've got to be willing to back up and say, "Hey, even though the calendar says we should be ready by this date, we're not there yet. We need to back up and make sure we do this the right way."

02:38

So, what does that look like in real life? In our return-to-throwing protocols, we involve some long toss, of course, but we also integrate constraint-led drills that are going to alter the movement patterns that contributed to the problem in the first place. We have to manage workload while we do that, and we have to manage intensity and stress. We can't just blindly throw; we have to reorganize the movement pattern so it becomes a safer way to throw in the future.