Why does my son throw hard in the bullpen but not in games?
A pitcher who throws harder in the bullpen than in games is solving a different problem in each environment. Bullpens are predictable and self-paced. Games add hitters, baserunners, and consequence, which change timing and often produce guiding rather than throwing. This is a skill transfer problem, not a strength problem.
It is not a mental problem
Ninety-one in the pen on Tuesday, eighty-six on Friday night. Same kid, same arm, same week. Most people explain that with the word mental. He is a gamer or he is not. He needs to be tougher.
That explanation is almost always wrong, and it is never useful, because it does not tell you what to change on Monday.
A bullpen and a game are not the same task
They only look the same. In a bullpen, nothing is coming at him. He chooses when to throw. The catcher is already set. There is no hitter to read, no runner to hold, no clock, and no consequence attached to the pitch. He can repeat the same movement at his own pace.
In a game, every one of those conditions is different. He is reading a hitter, holding a runner, working on somebody else's timing, and every pitch has a result. So he practiced one task and then went out and performed a different one. The delivery he built in the quiet place does not survive contact with the loud one.
Two ideas from motor learning explain this. The first is representative design: what an athlete does in practice should resemble the conditions of competition, including the information he is responding to, not only the movement he is making. The second is perception-action coupling: in any skill that requires responding to changing information, separating the perceiving from the doing prevents transfer. A standard bullpen strips out the perceiving and drills the doing.
What to do about it
The usual prescription is more bullpens, which is more practice at the task that is not transferring. Make the practice resemble the game instead.
-
- Put a hitter in the box, even one who is not swinging.
- Put a runner on and make him hold.
- Work on a clock rather than at his own pace.
- Call sequences instead of letting him choose every pitch.
- Vary the mound and the conditions.
- Attach a consequence to the pitch so there is something to compete against.
Expect it to get uglier before it gets better, and expect bullpen velocity to drop. That is not a problem. That is the number becoming honest.
When this doesn't apply
If the gap between bullpen and game velocity appeared suddenly rather than being a long-standing pattern, check the arm first. Velocity that drops in games before it drops in practice can also be an early sign of fatigue or discomfort the athlete has not reported.
Listen for the substitute words. Tight, weak, dead, fatigued, sore, heavy, and every vague variant. Treat all of them as the same report.
Related questions
Video Transcript: Why Does My Son Throw Hard in the Bullpen But Not in Games?
The Disconnect Between Bullpen and Game Velocity
Why does my son throw hard in the bullpen and not in games? Ninety-one mph in the bullpen on Tuesday and then Saturday 86 mph in the game? It's not that common, but it does happen, and it's something that we need to deal with.
Coaches will often say, "Oh, it's mental. He's just not a gamer. He's not tough enough." And I think that's nearly always wrong, and it's certainly not useful. You see, the bullpen and the game are two different environments requiring two different tasks. And so, it's two different skills.
In the bullpen, he decides when he throws. Whenever he's ready, he's throwing into a catcher or a nine-pocket. There are no runners. There's no chaos from the environment of the game.
Then he gets in the game and he's sometimes on a pitch clock. He has to go at the tempo of the game. He has to pick to first base or hold a runner on second. He has to be quicker to the plate. He doesn't get to throw all his pitches in blocks; he throws them in variable sequences. And then there's the pressure of the game, the excitement, and the adrenaline.
Motor Learning Science and Representative Design
Part of the problem is that he's practiced one skill during the week, and he's performing a whole different task in the game. In motor learning and motor control science, there's this concept called representative design.
Representative design means you have to make the practice resemble the game as much as possible to get the practice to transfer over to the game. That's why in hitting, hitting off a tee or hitting off a machine isn't the same as hitting off a live pitcher. It is exactly the same for pitchers in their bullpens.
Replicating Game Stimulus in Practice
We have to make the bullpen at least resemble the game as much as possible. We don't want to throw all of our pitches in blocks—like, "Here's all my fastballs, here's all my curveballs, here's my changeups"—because that's not how it works in a game.
I watch guys throwing bullpens and they'll do the whole bullpen out of the windup. Well, there are times in a game where you're only in the windup for one pitch, and then you've got to go from the stretch.
So, in a bullpen, we need to make at least 70% of our pitches from the stretch. We need to practice different timings on our holds. We need to put different situations in, create mock scenarios where we have fake runners on base, or actually do simulated games where we can replicate all that stimulus that we get. You've got to make sure that the bullpen is representative of all the task and environmental concerns we have in a game.
Developing Adaptable and Robust Athletes
I think the key is to create athletes who are adaptable and robust. We spend decades trying to get pitchers to have repeatable mechanics—to make the same delivery over and over and over again.
It's like having the same golf swing on the driving range over and over again. Then you get on the course and you've got a downhill lie, an uphill lie, you're in the rough, you're in the fairway, or you're in the sand. It's the same in pitching.
We try to create this perfect, mechanically sterile athlete who repeats his motion over and over again. Then he gets in a game and there are environmental variables like wind, temperature, rain, and a mound that is either too hard, too soft, or has a massive hole from being the sixth guy throwing on it in a tournament.
The environment changes. The task changes. The hitter is there, and the situation is different. You're trying to throw to a spot; you're not trying to just throw a strike. You're trying to avoid hard contact or induce a double play. That task is completely different than throwing to a catcher or a nine-pocket in the bullpen.
And then the organism—the athlete—is sometimes fatigued. Man, there are so many variables in the athlete, including nutrition, hydration, and sleep. But also in our training, everyone that comes into a facility wants to throw their bullpen when they're fresh.