Why do so many pitchers reinjure their arms after rehab?
Little league elbow is medial epicondyle apophysitis, an irritation of the growth plate on the inside of the elbow. It affects athletes roughly ages 6 to 15, because that growth plate does not fuse until around age 15. It is a growth plate condition rather than a ligament injury, and it requires evaluation by a physician.
The pattern every baseball family recognizes
He gets hurt. He rests, he rehabs, he gets cleared. He comes back, throws well for a few weeks, and then the same arm goes again in the same place.
Families tend to blame bad luck, a bad doctor, or a bad therapist. It is usually none of those. Getting cleared means the structure healed. It does not mean the system that broke it has changed.
Gap one: tissue that healed without stress
Consider what happens during a long shutdown. An athlete has spent months putting microscopic trauma into every piece of connective tissue in that arm. Then he stops completely, and healing begins with no load on it.
Connective tissue organizes along the lines of force it is asked to handle, and it gets that organization from being loaded while it heals. Remove the load entirely and the repair lays down without direction, producing a patch that is strong in no particular orientation.
When he begins throwing again, that disorganized tissue is the most vulnerable it will ever be. This is part of why so many arms fail early in a comeback rather than late in a season.
Gap two: rehab restored the tissue, nobody restored the task
Physical therapy is good at range of motion, strength, and pain. Those are the right targets and every returning athlete needs all three.
But throwing a baseball is not a range of motion. It is a whole-body skill performed at extremely high speed, and it has to be rebuilt as a skill, under load, in stages. A pitcher can have a perfect examination and still be nowhere near ready to compete, because nothing in his rehabilitation asked his body to do the thing that injured it.
Gap three: nobody found out why it happened
Something caused the injury, and usually several things stacked together. A physical restriction. A movement pattern that funneled stress onto one structure. How he prepared and recovered. How he trained. His workload across two teams. His sleep.
Rest addresses none of those. It removes the load for a period of time.
So an athlete who was never assessed returns into the same conditions that produced the injury, except now he is also deconditioned and his tissue is disorganized. That is not a fresh start. It is a worse one than he had before he got hurt.
The fourth problem, which is the calendar
Even when everything above is handled well, the return gets compressed, because there is a season waiting.
Every week completely off requires roughly two weeks of ramping back up. An athlete who missed ten weeks needs something like twenty to return properly. When the tryout date does not allow for that, the tryout date is the thing that has to move.
The question worth asking
Before a pitcher goes back out, the useful question is not whether he is healed. It is what is different now.
If nobody can answer that, he is going back into the same storm with a patched arm.
When this doesn't apply
This page describes a pattern, not a diagnosis of any individual athlete. If your son is under a physician's or a surgeon's care, that team's protocol governs his return. Nothing here replaces it, and a reinjury is not evidence that his medical care was wrong.
Related questions
Video Transcript: Why Do So Many Pitchers Reinjure Their Arm After Rehab?
The Cyclical Nature of Pitching Injuries
Why do so many pitchers reinjure their arm after rehab? We've seen it time and time again. A guy comes in, he's got an injury, we rest, do the physical therapy, and make the muscles around it stronger.
We get the guy cleared to return to throw, and then he goes to start throwing again and he's hurt again. It happens in this cyclical manner over and over again. Well, why does it happen?
Davis's Law and Why Complete Rest Fails
Well, first of all, complete rest is not the answer. You see, there's a law in physiology called Davis's law that says that all human tissue organizes itself to resist the stressors under which we place it.
So as we heal, if we don't add any stress to the arm and we just rest, the tissue organizes chaotically—like a plate of spaghetti noodles you left in the sink all night.
We have to take that tissue and turn it into tissue that is pliable, that conforms to the stresses that it must be required to endure. That means we can't just simply rest. We have to have active rest. We have to begin to move the arm earlier than most people want to.
The Flaw in Traditional Return-to-Throwing Programs
The other reason that they get hurt when they come back is because we didn't change any of the contributing variables. We send them out, we do the rehab, and we send them out with a return-to-throwing program that's the same as it was back in the '80s—and then we expect that that's going to produce magical results.
If that's the assumption, then the assumption is that overuse was the only cause for the injury. It's rarely just overuse. It's overuse in the wrong way. It's moving in the wrong way too much.
Addressing the Root Cause of Tissue Failure
So, what we have to do is take a systematic approach and look at what are the contributing variables that can mitigate the stress that caused the injury to begin with. Just because we get cleared to throw doesn't mean we fixed the system that broke it.
Oftentimes we see that rehab restored the tissue, but it didn't get it prepared to endure the stress of actual throwing. The biggest thing we have to appreciate is that something caused the injury; something led to it.
It's probably not one thing. It's probably a confluence of many different variables. But if we just simply rest and return to throw, it's pretty likely that we're going to come back again and find that we're hurt again because we didn't really change anything.
Breaking the Injury Cycle with Active Rest
Nothing changes if nothing changes, and so we're going to expect the same cycle over and over again. You have to break out of the cycle. You have to go to active rest.
You have to begin to move the arm within safe limits as soon as possible. Then you have to identify the contributing variables and eliminate them so that we don't have this cycle of injury, rest, recovery, and injury over and over again.